The Truth

The threat
"Are you unaware of identity theft? I am contacting the attorney general of my state to ask  for protection from your site."
  <>
Tamera Norwood 


Quoted from an email sent by Tamera Norwood on 15 February, 2011 to myself.
The information in question is name, date and location of birth (publicly available information, if I am not mistaken)

The Law
Indiana Code 35-43-5 Forgery, Fraud, and Other Deceptions.
Section 3.5 follows (emphasis mine)
IC 35-43-5-3.5
Identity deception
     Sec. 3.5. (a) Except as provided in subsection (b), a person who knowingly or intentionally obtains, possesses, transfers, or uses the identifying information of another person:
        (1) without the other person's consent; and
         (2) with intent to:
            (A) harm or defraud another person;          
            (B) assume another person's identity; or
            (C) profess to be another person;
commits identity deception, a Class D felony.
    (b) The conduct prohibited in subsection (a) does not apply to:
        (1) a person less than twenty-one (21) years of age who uses the identifying information of another person to acquire an      alcoholic beverage (as defined in IC 7.1-1-3-5);
        (2) a minor (as defined in IC 35-49-1-4) who uses the identifying information of another person to acquire:
            (A) a cigarette or tobacco product (as defined in IC 6-7-2-5);
            (B) a periodical, a videotape, or other communication medium that contains or depicts nudity (as defined in IC 35-49-1-5);
            (C) admittance to a performance (live or film) that prohibits the attendance of the minor based on age; or
            (D) an item that is prohibited by law for use or consumption by a minor; or
        (3) any person who uses the identifying information for a lawful purpose.
    (c) It is not a defense in a prosecution under subsection (a) that no person was harmed or defrauded.
As added by P.L.180-2001, SEC.2. Amended by P.L.22-2003, SEC.2.


On the other hand:
IC 35-45-2-1
Intimidation
     Sec. 1. (a) A person who communicates a threat to another person, with the intent:
        (1) that the other person engage in conduct against the other person's will;
        (2) that the other person be placed in fear of retaliation for a prior lawful act; or
        (3) of causing:
            (A) a dwelling, a building, or another structure; or
            (B) a vehicle;
        to be evacuated;
commits intimidation, a Class A misdemeanor.
 (c) "Threat" means an expression, by words or action, of an intention to:
        (1) unlawfully injure the person threatened or another person, or damage property;
        (2) unlawfully subject a person to physical confinement or restraint;
        (3) commit a crime;
        (4) unlawfully withhold official action, or cause such withholding;
        (5) unlawfully withhold testimony or information with respect to another person's legal claim or defense, except for a reasonable claim for witness fees or expenses;
        (6) expose the person threatened to hatred, contempt, disgrace, or ridicule;
        (7) falsely harm the credit or business reputation of the person
(emphasis mine)

You make  your own decision